Tuesday: 05.16.2006

Weekend Extended; Tigers Sweep.

null

A great Mother's Day weekend has been extended as I decided to stick around with the family for a few more days. That said, I still wanted to jump on and drop a few notes. I was very pleased to see the Detroit Tigers sweep the Cleveland Indians. As the Detroit Tigers Weblog breaks down, it wasn't the prettiest of series sweeps, but the Tigers took care of business nonetheless. Meanwhile, the Detroit Free Press points out how the little plays, particularly a fielding effort by Vance Wilson, were instrumental to the dismantling of the Tribe.

Another key has to be how the Tigers were able to shutout catcher Victor Martinez, holding him to an 0-for-12 weekend. Only Milwaukee's Damian Miller has a higher VORP for catchers in all of baseball. Martinez has been one of the best hitters in all of baseball so far this season hitting .319/.378/.504.

One point of contention by DTW was that the Tigers might be the benefactors of some luck regarding when they are playing teams. Here is what they said:

They faced the Rangers without their best pitchers, they faced the Twins when they were struggling, they faced the Athletics when they weren’t hitting, and they faced the Indians when nothing was going right for them.

Let me make it clear that I am not trying to slam DTW under any circumstance. I love the site and read it daily. That said, I cannot agree with the idea that the Tigers are simply catching teams at the right time. The Rangers did have their best pitchers against the Tigers, the Twins have been struggling all year long, not just when they face the Tigers, and the A's are hitting .243 (13th in AL)/.327 (10th)/.408 (9th) meaning they have not hit anyone as opposed to the Tigers catching them in a slump.

Against the Rangers, R.A. Dickey was the only weak pitcher faced. The Tigers rocked John Koronka and Kevin Millwood, but that is more credit to Detroit as the Rangers consider them two of their best pitchers. Koronka has been a pleasant surprise for the Rangers and holds the 14th best VORP in the American League for pitchers. Millwood has an inflated earned run average (5.31), but he holds the team's 4th best VORP for pitchers and a ridiculously high BABIP at .346. A 3:1 strikeout-to-walk ratio says he's pitching better than his ERA suggests.

Five and four game winning streaks in the 2nd weeks of April and May, respectively, are the only thing keeping the Twins ahead of the Kansas City Royals for the Central cellar. Outside of the league's best pitcher, Johan Santana, the pitching staff has been absolutely brutal. Luis Castillo (.835) and Joe Mauer (.806) are the only two hitters an OPS over .800. They seem to be righting the ship at least somewhat in May as they are finally playing Michael Cuddyer and two of their best hitters, Torii Hunter and Justin Morneau, are really starting to click at the plate. That said, their four highest May ERAs belong to their non-Santana starters, Jesse Crain still hasn't gotten things on track (6.75 ERA, 1.73 WHIP) despite a giant spike in strikeouts (up to 9.35 per nine from 2.82 in 2005), and the 53 home runs allowed is third worst in all of baseball. Are the Twins struggling as they face the Tigers or does facing the Tigers cause the Twins to continue and heighten their struggles? So far this season, I believe more in the latter.

Eric Chavez and Nick Swisher have been crushing the ball so far this season for Oakland, but beyond that, the team has not been able to hit their way out of a paper bag. After Chavez and Swisher, no regular player carries an OPS above .780. With two strong pieces in their lineup, they have been able to keep themselves from the cellar of league OPS, but with 7/9ths of the lineup producing very little all season, I don't think it's fair to say that the Tigers caught them when they weren't hitting.

As a Tigers-based blog, I know that DTW is not trying to tear down what the Tigers have done so far. Rather, they are keeping things in perspective to temper expectations, which I can appreciate, but I think that the first month and a half of play is sustainable as opposed to a matter of circumstance mixed with some key performances.

The Tigers return home for six straight, including an interleague opener against another surprise team in the Cincinnati Reds this weekend. The Reds are one of the two teams allowing more home runs (Toronto being the other) than the Minnesota Twins. Being that the Twins are the other team coming into town this week, it could be bombs away at Comerica Park this week.

Friday: 05.12.2006

Gone Until Monday.

The Tigers had a rainout last night due to some nasty weather terrorizing the entire east coast. Tonight, they begin a set in Cleveland. I’m headed home to see the family for the weekend, so I may or may not get something up after tonight’s game. Most likely it’ll be see ya on Monday!

Thursday: 05.11.2006

Verlander Solid, Lopez Not as Tigers Win.

Rejoice, the Tigers are winners once again! At any rate, I’ve been a mess today with a few other deadlines I’m running up against and I just checked in to drop the WPC and say that watching Joel Zumaya is pure, unadulterated fun.

Once again courtesy of FanGraphs.com:

null

Tomorrow, the Tigers aim to tame Erik Bedard in the rubber match. Yes, I just wanted to say “aim to tame.”

Tuesday: 05.9.2006

Aye, Carlos!

Despite a spectacular night at the plate turned in by Carlos Guillen that saw him go 2-for-2 with 3 walks and 3 runs batted in, it’s tough not to look in his direction when wondering how the Detroit Tigers lost the series opener to the Baltimore Orioles, 7-6. Fernando Rodney had a tough night out of the bullpen as well, but more on that in a second.

In the third inning, Guillen made an error on Melvin Mora grounder that extended the inning and gave Miguel Tejada a chance that he cashed in for a 2-run homer. It wasn’t the simplest of balls to field, but Guillen looked like he was rushing to make the play and after the ball popped out on the glove-to-hand exchange, he had a hurried throw to Pudge Rodriguez, playing first for the first time in his career. I mention Rodriguez’s first base debut matter of factly, not to implicate him.

Shortly after his bases clearing double in Tigers half of the 5th, Guillen inexplicably decided to attempt a steal of third base with one out and Dmitri Young at the dish. It seems any out you make at third, be it trying to stretch a double or attempting a steal, is highly admonished. What’s worse, is that after Young finished the at-bat with a walk, Daniel Cabrera‘s 7th of the game, Craig Monroe struck out and ended the inning. The Tigers had Cabrera on the ropes and were taking full advantage of his control problems I mentioned yesterday:

They head to Baltimore for a three-game set facing Daniel Cabrera in the opener. They need to exhibit more patience than they have so far and it will be rewarded by the control-leary Cabrera (25 walks in 32.1 IP).

Guillen’s rough night wasn’t done there. In the bottom of the 8th, he fumbled a routine grounder off the bat of Chris Gomez, again extending the inning, and the Orioles were able to cash in. Mora’s base hit scored pinch-runner Luis Terrero to seal the deal and cost the Tigers another ballgame they clearly should have won.

As a free-swinging team, I was worried that maybe the team wouldn’t let Cabrera hang himself with his control problems, but they were splendidly patient at the dish. Cabrera went five, and as I mentioned, walked seven. He also allowed five hits and five runs. Magglio Ordonez homered in the 7th off of Todd Williams for his 10th of the season.

In regular jinx-like fashion, as soon as The Detroit Tigers Weblog posts this about some media praise for the Tigers, including this nugget from Baseball Prospectus’ Joe Sheehan:

The key for the Tigers staff has been eliminating home runs. They’ve allowed just 22 in 30 games, second only to the Yankees for fewest bombs allowed, a figure that has helped them to the second-lowest slugging allowed in MLB.

Nate Robertson and Rodney go out and allow four bombs! Robertson was having Cabrera-like control issues with five walks of his own, and he was good enough to win tonight, but the Guillen error was a big blow. Rodney just had an off night and while as much as I hate to say it, he was due. And even he was good enough to get out of the jams, but his Guillen error did him in, too.

Back at it tomorrow evening with another struggling starting pitcher in Rodrigo Lopez. Justin Verlander toes the rubber for Tigers looking for his 4th win. I’ll post the WPC from FanGraphs.com once it becomes available. I’m sure it is all over the place with five ties & lead changes.

As promised:

Random Note:
Delmon Young received a 50-game suspension for his bat throwing incident, which I’m content with. I wouldn’t have minded more, but 50 is pretty good.

Monday: 05.8.2006

The Pace Game.

The season is just 32 games young, or rather 20% completed, and there has been plenty to love about the start of the Detroit Tigers. First off, though their home run hitting ability gets most of the press, it has been their superior starting pitching that has powered the team early on. Of course, I say that on the heels of dropping two of three to the Minnesota Twins. Jeremy Bonderman was knocked around a bit, Todd Jones blew his first save, and despite the best efforts of Mike Maroth, he ran into Johan Santana, who carried a no-hitter into the 7th inning. Nevertheless, things are looking great for the Tigers. I put together their numbers for the whole season based on the first 32 games. The offense:

Player  G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
 Magglio
Ordóñez
152 602 101 187 30 0 46 116 30 106 0 0 0.311 0.339 0.588 0.927
 Curtis
Granderson
162 587 86 147 30 5 25 61 96 162 15 10 0.250 0.353 0.448 0.801
 Craig
Monroe
162 587 91 137 25 0 41 101 30 162 5 0 0.233 0.274 0.483 0.757
 Chris
Shelton
162 582 91 172 30 15 51 106 51 172 0 0 0.296 0.364 0.661 1.025
 Carlos
Guillén
162 567 91 167 51 5 25 96 61 61 20 10 0.295 0.365 0.536 0.901
 Iván
Rodríguez
137 567 81 182 25 5 10 56 30 51 5 5 0.321 0.361 0.438 0.799
 Plácido
Polanco
132 547 41 157 5 0 0 51 5 20 0 10 0.287 0.304 0.296 0.600
 Brandon
Inge
152 486 91 116 30 5 35 86 51 142 0 10 0.240 0.312 0.542 0.854
 Marcus
Thames
76 218 46 66 10 0 20 30 15 25 0 0 0.302 0.375 0.628 1.003
 Dmitri
Young
51 203 25 51 15 0 0 20 10 46 5 0 0.250 0.286 0.325 0.611
 Omar
Infante
66 187 15 46 20 0 0 10 0 61 5 0 0.243 0.282 0.351 0.633
 Alexis
Gómez
66 182 35 41 10 5 0 10 10 30 0 0 0.222 0.263 0.333 0.596
 Ramón
Santiago
61 122 5 25 0 5 0 5 0 30 5 0 0.208 0.208 0.292 0.500
 Vance
Wilson
41 116 15 35 10 0 0 15 0 20 0 0 0.304 0.360 0.391 0.751
 Total 162 5554 815 1529 294 46 253 764 390 1088 61 46 0.275 0.329 0.481 0.810

Initially, I’m pleased with just how well Magglio Ordonez has been playing despite the fact that he’s not walking very much. If he is able to hold pace and play 152 games while hitting 40+ HRs, this team is going to be very successful. A few things that I don’t see happening at all include Chris Shelton‘s triple and home run totals being sustained. For Craig Monroe to come anywhere near 40 home runs, he’ll need to greatly improve his patience at the plate and take some walks. Curtis Granderson‘s pace for 96 walks is very pleasing. He is progressing nicely and the Tigers have to be thrilled with their leadoff man. I’m not at all concerned that Granderson is only on pace for 15 steals, moreso miffed that it is just a 60% success rate. If Carlos Guillen can play every game, that’d just be amazing. A 20-20 season would be icing on the cake. Brandon Inge will not hit 35 home runs, but Marcus Thames could if he finds some at-bats. Sooner or later, if Monroe continues to struggle, Jim Leyland will have to consider giving Thames more time at Monroe’s expense.

Now for the pitching:

 Player  G GS W L SV IP H R ER HR BB K ERA WHIP BAA
 Kenny
Rogers
35 35 25 10 0 233.9 197 86 86 15 61 116 3.28 1.09 0.223
 Jeremy
Bonderman
35 35 15 10 0 227.8 197 111 111 15 51 197 4.40 1.09 0.231
 Justin
Verlander
30 30 15 15 0 183.3 167 86 76 30 56 116 3.68 1.20 0.239
 Nate
Robertson
30 30 15 10 0 182.3 162 76 66 15 46 137 3.25 1.14 0.237
 Mike
Maroth
30 30 20 10 0 177.7 187 51 51 15 66 76 2.55 1.42 0.270
 Jordan
Tata
35 0 0 0 0 70.9 46 35 30 5 35 30 3.86 1.14 0.180
 Joel
Zumaya
56 0 5 0 0 65.8 46 20 20 5 15 81 2.77 0.92 0.196
 Fernando
Rodney
66 0 5 0 25 65.8 20 0 0 0 20 61 0.00 0.62 0.093
 Jason
Grilli
35 0 0 0 0 56.7 66 35 35 0 30 20 5.40 1.63 0.289
 Jamie
Walker
46 0 0 0 0 41.5 30 5 5 5 0 51 1.04 0.69 0.188
 Bobby
Seay
35 0 0 0 0 40.5 10 10 10 0 15 30 2.25 0.63 0.083
 Todd
Jones
41 0 0 5 30 35.9 51 25 25 0 10 10 6.14 1.64 0.333
 Total     101 61 56 1382.1 1180 542 516 106 405 926 3.38 1.15 0.230

Kenny Rogers almost certainly won’t win 25 games, but he has been a great addition to the Tigers despite all the griping (from myself included) about his large contract. There is just no way that a bullpen will only be responsible for 15 decisions in a season, the wins and losses paces of individual pitchers is a tad ridiculous. I wish Mike Maroth would win 20, though, he deserves it. The strikeout paces of most of the bullpen are very encouraging. Rodney, Seay, Walker, & Zumaya are on pace for excellent strikeout-to-walk ratios… especially Walker as he has yet to walk a batter.

I’ll update these paces several times throughout the season as they will start to even out, undoubtedly. Right now, the Tigers need to rebound from a tough series in which the Twins really came to play. They head to Baltimore for a three-game set facing Daniel Cabrera in the opener. They need to exhibit more patience than they have so far and it will be rewarded by the control-leary Cabrera (25 walks in 32.1 IP).

Friday: 05.5.2006

Off to Minnesota

Given the early season success the Tigers have enjoyed, it’s hard to complain about losses because they are going to happen from time to time, but this one was bad. Not only did they allow a pitcher (Kevin Gregg) making his first start of the season to look great, but the staff allowed at least one hit to each batter in an atrocious lineup.

AB R H RBI BB SO LOB AVG
Chone Figgins, 3B 4 0 2 0 1 0 1 0.288
Orlando Cabrera, SS 5 1 1 0 0 1 3 0.286
Vladimir Guerrero, RF 5 1 4 3 0 0 2 0.327
Garret Anderson, LF 4 1 1 0 1 0 2 0.294
Adam Kennedy, 2B 5 0 2 0 0 0 4 0.322
Casey Kotchman, 1B 4 1 1 1 0 0 4 0.164
Howie Kendrick, DH 3 1 1 1 0 1 0 0.143
Mike Napoli, C 4 1 1 1 0 0 2 0.250
Tommy Murphy, CF 4 1 2 1 0 0 0 0.500
Totals 38 7 15 7 2 2 18  

Essentially four rookies (Kotchman played 85 games prior to ’06) at the bottom of the order going 5-for-15 with two home runs (Kotchman and Napoli) and four runs batted in. Two of the rookies were called up that day! Meanwhile Gregg, Brendan Donnelly, and Francisco Rodriguez hold the Tigers to four hits and two runs. The Win Probability Chart from Fangraphs.com shows that things looked doomed from the start on Thursday:

I’m not going to throw out everything the Tigers have accomplished to this point and suggest they’ve been frauds in their hot start. I just don’t like “losing the ones you shouldn’t.” It is like losing to the Kansas City Royals. You know it can happen, it just shouldn’t! Maybe I’m just bummed that this was Justin Verlander‘s first start for my fantasy team since I acquired him and he got touched up. The team is off to Minnesota to start a nine-game roadie.

Tonight:
Detroit – Kenny Rogers (4-2, 2.59)
Minnesota – Kyle Lohse (1-2, 8.77)

Wednesday: 05.3.2006

Binge Drinking: A Cool Six-Pack

Jeff Weaver threw 74 of his 113 pitches for strikes tonight, including a fat one to Brandon Inge that was sent over the fence to tie the game. On several occassions, Weaver was visibly upset with home plate umpire “Country” Joe West. West, in Weaver’s mind, was squeezing too tight of a zone and not calling several pitches on the black. Shortly after one such incident, he made his mistake pitch and Inge made him pay. Weaver stayed strong, however, because despite allowing a triple to the very next batter, Ramon Santiago, he got out of the jam and held the game at 1-1.

Fast forward to the eighth inning. Once again Inge caused troubled, drawing a walk off of Weaver right after a Craig Monroe strikeout. Then, on a groundball to second, Inge managed to avoid being put out on the fielder’s choice giving the Tigers 1st and 2nd with two outs. Two outs haven’t bothered the Tigers in their homestand at all and Alexis Gomez delivered a single to score Inge for the go-ahead and eventual winning run in Wednesday’s 2-1 win.

Starter Nate Robertson, who left with a no-decision, struck out six, walked two, and allowed four hits with his lone blemish coming in the first inning on a Vladimir Guerrero sac fly. Joel Zumaya and Fernando Rodney teamed to close the door and extend the Tigers’ winning streak to six games. According to mlb.com, “The Tigers have allowed just five runs over their last six games, tied for the best streak in franchise history and last accomplished in July 1986.”

In 71 innings of work, the bullpen has struck out 51 while walking 25. They have collected a 1.06 WHIP and allowed With Todd Jones returning, the Tigers have a powerful two-closer combo with he and Rodney. Jones, Rodney, and Zumaya all rank in the top 25 for relievers in Baseball Prospectus’ Expected Wins (WX). Jamie Walker ranks 26th.

In tomorrow’s getaway day, Justin Verlander (3-2, 3.52) squares off against Kevin Gregg (1-0, 0.84), who is making his first start of the season. The team then heads out on a nine-game road trip visiting Minnesota, Baltimore, and Cleveland.

The Win Probability Graph from FanGraphs.com
May 3rd WPG

Tuesday: 05.2.2006

Trade Redux: 2002

On June 26, 2002, the Montreal Expos were 41-36 and seven games behind the Atlanta Braves for the lead in the National League East.  They were the surprise team of the season thus far led by Vladimir Guerrero.  The team had a host of young starters including Tony Armas Jr. (24), Tomo Ohka (26), and Javier Vazquez (26).  A 26-year old by the name of Carl Pavano was struggling to round out the rotation and the team knew that if they were to catch the Braves, they would need to solidify the rotation.  Enter the Cleveland Indians.  Armed (pun-intended) with one of the best pitchers in all of baseball at the time, they dangled Bartolo Colon in front of the Expos.

Colon, 27 years old at the time, was 10-4 with a 2.55 earned run average in 116.1 innings pitched.  He had 41.2 VORP (Value Over Replacement Player) according to Baseball Prospectus.  I cannot tell where that ranked at the time, though I presume top five at worst, but it was good enough for 16th in the American League for the entire season of 2002.  The Indians sent the right-hander with Tim Drew to the Expos for uber-prospect Brandon Phillips, Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore, and Lee Stevens.  Phillips was rated the #1 prospect in the Montreal Expos system at the beginning of 2002 according to Baseball America.  Sizemore ranked third and Lee just missed the Top 10 coming in at 11th.  Drew was chip-in with Colon, but did rate 12th in the Indians minor leagues. 

At the time, the key pieces were obviously Colon and Phillips, and little was known of the other parts outside of veteran Stevens.  Fast forward to 2006 and we have a much different story.  How did things work out for both teams in the 2002 summer deal?

Bartolo Colon
Colon went over to Montreal and nearly matched his early season success from Cleveland.  He posted a record of 10-4 as well as doubling his complete games total to eight in 117 innings pitched.  He 22.9 VORP with the Expos good enough for 31st overall amongst starters with 115 or more innings pitched in the National League.  The Expos eventually faded, despite this and another deal that acquired Cliff Floyd, in their pursuit of the Atlanta Braves.  They finished 19 games back in 2nd place.  Colon was dealt in that offseason to the Chicago White Sox for Rocky Biddle, Orlando Hernandez, and Jeff Liefer. 

Cliff Lee
Lee pitched in three levels with the Indians in that second part of the 2002 including a cup of coffee with the big league team.  All told, including his time with Montreal's AA affiliate in Harrisburg, Lee struck out 159 batters in 156 innings.  The 24-year old's control wasn't excellent with 63 walks, but he showed promise.  His performance was good enough to merit the #3 ranking for the Indians in the 2003 minor league rankings.  In 2003, he pitched just under 80 innings (79.2) in three different levels and while he was able to nearly sustain his strikeout rates dropping from 9.15 to 8.81 per nine, his already poor walk rate shot up from 3.63 to 4.29 per nine innings.  In June, he was called up to the Indians and has been there since.  He pitched nine games with the big-league club and brought his walk rate back down allowing 3.45 per nine, but also dropping his strikeout rate to 7.60 per nine innings.  After an up-and-down 2004, Lee used last season to establish himself as one of the premier lefties in the American League.  He traded in overwhelming strikeout numbers for more control posting a 2.32 walks per nine rate, the lowest in any of his career stops. 

Year Team Name League Age Org. Level W L ERA G GS IP H R ER HR BB SO WHIP BB/9 K/9
2002 Akron East 24 Cle AA 2 1 5.40 3 3 16.67 11 11 10 1 10 18 1.26 5.40 9.72
2002 Harrisburg East 24 Mtl AA 7 2 3.23 15 15 86.33 61 31 31 12 23 105 0.97 2.40 10.95
2002 Buffalo IL 24 Cle AAA 3 2 3.77 8 8 43 36 18 18 7 22 30 1.35 4.60 6.28
2002 Cleveland Indians MLB 24 Cle MLB 0 1 1.74 2 2 10.33 6 2 2 0 8 6 1.35 6.97 5.23
2002 TOTAL         12 6 3.51 28 28 156.33 114 62 61 20 63 159 1.13 3.63 9.15
2003 Kinston Caro 25 Cle A+ 0 0 0.00 1 1 4.33 0 1 0 0 3 4 0.69 6.24 8.31
2003 Akron East 25 Cle AA 1 1 1.50 2 2 12 7 2 2 1 4 13 0.92 3.00 9.75
2003 Buffalo IL 25 Cle AAA 6 1 3.27 11 11 63.33 62 24 23 4 31 61 1.47 4.41 8.67
2003 Cleveland Indians MLB 25 Cle MLB 3 3 3.61 9 9 52.1 41 28 21 7 20 44 1.17 3.45 7.60
2003 TOTAL         10 5 3.14 23 23 131.76 110 55 46 12 58 122 1.28 3.96 8.33
2004 Cleveland Indians MLB 26 Cle MLB 14 8 5.43 33 33 179 188 113 108 30 81 161 1.50 4.07 8.09
2005 Cleveland Indians MLB 27 Cle MLB 18 5 3.79 32 32 202 194 91 85 22 52 143 1.22 2.32 6.37

 

Brandon Phillips
The 2003 season marked the second time that Phillips would head his team's list of minor league prospects, taking the number one spot with the Indians as well.  That was as bright as star would shine with the Indians organization.  He posted a .300/.336/.493 line in 136 games in 2002, but then followed it up with an abysmal .198/.261/.302 line in 146 games between AAA and the majors in 2003.  He spent all but six of his 146 games in 2004 with the AAA team for the Indians and seemed to find himself once again.  Phillips feel off of the top 10 list for Indians prospects at the start of 2004, but had a .291/.331/.410 line and slowly started to once again gain some believers.  It was a short-lived rejuvenation.  Phillips was again sank into mediocrity in 2005 hitting .256/.326/.409 in 112 games with AAA Buffalo last year.  The bandwagon was almost entirely evacuated save for one Wayne Krivsky.  Krivsky, the new general manager for the Cincinnati Reds, acquired Phillips for a PTBNL and some cash.  For now, Phillips's career has experienced a much-needed resuscitation with the Reds.  He has hit .343/.375/.567 with 9.3 VORP in 72 plate appearances.  He certainly didn't deliver the dividends the Indians expected when they dealt Colon that summer.

Year Team Name League Age Org. Level G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO AVG OBP SLG OPS
1999 GCL Expos GCL 18 Mtl Rk 47 169 23 49 11 3 1 21 12 3 15 35 0.290 0.352 0.408 760
2000 Cape Fear SAL 19 Mtl A 126 484 74 117 17 8 11 72 23 8 38 97 0.242 0.306 0.378 684
2001 Jupiter FSL 20 Mtl A+ 55 194 36 55 12 2 4 23 17 3 38 45 0.284 0.404 0.428 832
2001 Harrisburg East 20 Mtl AA 67 265 35 79 19 0 7 36 13 6 12 42 0.298 0.333 0.449 782
2002 Buffalo IL 21 Cle AAA 55 223 30 63 14 0 8 27 8 2 14 39 0.283 0.321 0.453 774
2002 Ottawa IL 21 Mtl AAA 10 35 1 9 4 0 1 5 0 0 2 6 0.257 0.297 0.457 754
2002 Cleveland Indians MLB 21 Cle MLB 11 31 5 8 3 1 0 4 0 0 3 6 0.258 0.343 0.419 762
2002 TOTAL   21     143 554 71 159 40 1 16 72 21 8 31 93 0.287 0.325 0.475 830
2003 Buffalo IL 22 Cle AAA 43 154 14 27 7 0 3 13 7 3 12 22 0.175 0.247 0.279 526
2003 Cleveland Indians MLB 22 Cle MLB 112 370 36 77 18 1 6 33 4 5 14 77 0.208 0.242 0.311 553
2003 TOTAL   22     155 524 50 104 25 1 9 46 11 8 26 99 0.198 0.256 0.302 763
2004 Buffalo IL 23 Cle AAA 140 551 88 163 34 4 8 50 14 11 44 56 0.296 0.353 0.416 769
2004 Cleveland Indians MLB 23 Cle MLB 6 22 1 4 2 0 0 1 0 2 2 5 0.182 0.250 0.273 523
2004 TOTAL   23     146 573 89 167 36 4 8 51 14 13 46 61 0.291 0.331 0.410 788
2005 Buffalo IL 24 Cle AAA 112 465 79 119 24 1 15 46 7 5 39 90 0.256 0.326 0.409 735
2005 Cleveland Indians MLB 24 Cle MLB 6 9 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.000 0.000 0.000 0
2005 TOTAL   24     118 474 80 119 24 1 15 46 7 5 39 94 0.251 0.315 0.401 870

 

Grady Sizemore
Though hardly a throw-in, Sizemore, as I mentioned, didn't come over with nearly as much acclaim as Phillips.  He hit the majors at age 18 and immediately made a splash in rookie league with a .293/.380/.376 line and 16 stolen bases in 55 games.  That was good enough to give him #6 spot in Montreal's 2001 rankings.  What was true then in true now.  His weaknesses, as noted by Baseball America's Michael Levesque, were: "Sizemore has average arm strength and still displays some stiffness in his throwing stroke because of his football background. Montreal officials believe it will smooth out with time. He has trouble catching up to anything up in the strike zone."  In 2001, he balanced out his 92 strikeouts with 81 walks, excellent for a 19-year old.  He put up .268/.383/.335 totals in A-ball.  That performance, as I noted earlier, was good enough for 3rd overall in the Expos organization.  He played in High-A ball for both the Expos and then the Indians and was able to once limit the damage of his strikeouts with a 1.03 K:BB ratio.  Sizemore started 2003 as the 7th rated prospect in Cleveland's farm system, but he was the third ranked prospect from the Colon trade behind Lee and Phillips.  That was the first season that Sizemore started to exhibit some power with 50 of his 151 hits going for extra bases including 13 home runs.  He went .304/.373/.480 in AA that season.  That gave him the top spot in the Indians system to start 2004 and he delivered.  In 102 AAA games, Sizemore posted a .288/.361/.440 line including 40 extra base hits.  That earned him a 43-game stint with the big league where he scuffled a little bit, but still went .246/.333/.406.  From there, Sizemore enjoyed last year's breakout season going 20/20 with 22 home runs and stolen bases.  He hit .289/.348/.484, but did strikeout 132 times with only 52 walks.  He is off to fine start this season, but is averaging over a strikeout per game with 27 in 26 games. 

Year Team Name League Age Org. Level G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO AVG OBP SLG OPS
2000 GCL Expos GCL 18 Mtl Rk 55 205 31 60 8 3 1 14 16 2 23 24 0.293 0.380 0.376 756
2001 Clinton Midw 19 Mtl A 123 451 64 121 16 4 2 61 32 11 81 92 0.268 0.383 0.335 718
2002 Brevard County FSL 20 Mtl A+ 75 256 37 66 15 4 0 26 9 9 36 41 0.258 0.351 0.348 699
2002 Kinston Caro 20 Cle A+ 47 172 31 59 9 3 3 20 14 7 33 30 0.343 0.451 0.483 934
2002 TOTAL         300 428 68 125 24 7 3 46 23 16 69 71 0.292 0.358 0.402 760
2003 Akron East 21 Cle AA 128 496 96 151 26 11 13 78 10 9 46 73 0.304 0.373 0.480 853
2004 Buffalo IL 22 Cle AAA 102 423 75 122 24 8 8 51 16 10 42 72 0.288 0.361 0.440 801
2004 Cleveland Indians MLB 22 Cle MLB 43 138 15 34 6 2 4 24 2 0 14 34 0.246 0.333 0.406 739
2004 TOTAL         145 561 90 156 30 10 12 75 18 10 56 106 0.278 0.336 0.431 767
2005 Cleveland Indians MLB 23 Cle MLB 158 640 111 185 37 11 22 81 22 10 52 132 0.289 0.348 0.484 832

It is interesting to go back and see how things have shaken out in a big-time deal. Obviously, the Indians got the better of it long-term, but the Expos knew they were sacrificing some future earnings for immediate gains. The odd part is the significant gains for the Indians came from the secondary sources of the trade while Phillips fizzled out with the Indians. It also goes to show you how uncertain the art of prospecting can be. Sizemore and Lee weren’t spares by any means, but no one would’ve forecasted their futures to be brighter than Phillips’s and now both sit on the cusp of stardom. This is one of several trade reviews I have planned for the site. I think it is both fun and interesting to look back and gauge how things turned out against the perception of the trade at the time it was made.

References:
Baseball America
Baseball Cube
Baseball Prospectus
Retrosheet

Monday: 05.1.2006

Month in Review

The following is my weekly column found also at Sportsblurb.com

American League East:
New York Yankees (13-10): The Yankees are only on pace for 864 runs scored after the first month of this season. However, they find themselves in first place despite three starters carrying earned run averages over 4.50. Most impressive is the 2.64 collective earned run average of the bullpen in 64 and two-thirds innings.
Player of the Month: Mike Mussina
Dud of the Month: Mariano Rivera

Boston Red Sox (14-11): Posting the record they have despite allowing more runs than they have scored (127 to 117) is a surprise. Jon Papelbon has been a smashing success and allowed Keith Foulke (0.76 WHIP) to settle into a role where he doesn’t cost the team an exorbitant amount of games. Curt Schilling has returned to form, but Matt Clement is still brutal. No wonder they have offered Roger Clemens the world to come to Boston.
Player of the Month: Mike Lowell
Dud of the Month: Mark Loretta

Toronto Blue Jays (12-11): Hitting the ball hasn’t been a problem with the addition of Troy Glaus and Vernon Wells’ emergence from his April funk (sub-.650 career OPS). Unfortunately, the staff has allowed similar levels of hitting to the other team on a regular basis. A.J. Burnett has, predictably, been a colossal bust and only Roy Halladay and Gustavo Chacin are consistently making starts.
Player of the Month: Wells
Dud of the Month: Burnett

Baltimore Orioles (13-13): The Orioles have to be pleased with a .500 record after one month given their pitching staff woes. Inconsistent doesn’t begin to describe the talented Daniel Cabrera, Bruce Chen and Rodrigo Lopez look awful on the mound, leaving Erik Bedard and Kris Benson as the only worthwhile starters. Chris Ray has been excellent in filling the B.J. Ryan void at closer. The team closed out the month with three straight series losses and now had to put Brian Roberts on the disabled list with a groin injury.
Player of the Month: Miguel Tejada
Dud of the Month: Chen

Tampa Bay Devil Rays (11-14): A familiar position for the team, but they are only three games out. I don’t mean to imply they can contend, but all the new-season hope hasn’t faded for them yet. The pitching remains awful in Tampa Bay. Scott Kazmir is the obvious focal point to build around, but still lacks a great deal of control. Every other bit of the staff is garbage. Jonny Gomes has picked up the slack in a big way for Aubrey Huff and Julio Lugo, but he hasn’t had enough help and now Jorge Cantu takes his .814 OPS to the disabled list.
Player of the Month: Gomes
Dud of the Month: Travis Lee

American League Central:

Chicago White Sox (17-7): The World Champions have revamped their approach to offense and now muscle the way back to home plate with 33 home runs. Much of that has to do with the arrival of the rejuvenated Jim Thome. He has sparked this offense to excellence. If it weren’t for this newfound offense, the Sox might not be doing as well considering two-fifths of the rotation has posted a 6.52 earned run average. It appears as though Jon Garland’s contract with the devil has been non-tendered and he’s been designated for assignment.
Player of the Month: Jose Contreras
Dud of the Month: Scott Podsednik

Detroit Tigers (16-9): With all the talk surrounding the team’s home run surge, specifically focused on Chris Shelton, the unbelievable start by the pitching staff gets lost in the shuffle. The staff leads baseball in earned run average, OPS-against, batting average-against, and WHIP. Their five shutouts are also a league best. Powered by a 33-1 three-game thrashing of the Minnesota Twins, the team leads baseball in home runs with 38 and the American League in total bases with 414.
Player of the Month: Shelton, the pitching rotation
Dud of the Month: Placido Polanco (despite yesterday’s defensive gem)

Cleveland Indians (13-12): Who knows how high this team’s earned run average (5.52) would be if it weren’t for Cliff Lee and Jason Johnson? The two have been the only stabling factors in the entire staff. The team will welcome back C.C. Sabathia, who went down just three innings into the season, this week. Travis Hafner and Victor Martinez lead an explosive offense, but the top of the order needs to stop striking out. Grady Sizemore, Jason Michaels, and Jhonny Peralta have combined for 73 whiffs so far.
Player of the Month: Martinez
Dud of the Month: Paul Byrd

Minnesota Twins (9-15): They should thank the Royals for existing and saving them from the depths of the AL Central basement. This team has so many problems linked to hitting, pitching, and defense that it’s tough to know where to start the healing process. The best place to start would be with a youth movement including Jason Bartlett, Jason Kubel, and Francisco Liriano.
Player of the Month: Luis Castillo
Dud of the Month: Kyle Lohse, Brad Radke, and Carlos Silva

Kansas City Royals (5-17): No real surprises here and many projected the Royals to be one of the worst teams in all of baseball. The best part of this team, closer Ambiorix Burgos, is hardly ever used because they are rarely in a position to win. Mark Grudzielanek is the only regular hitting above .266.
Player of the Month: Shane Costa
Dud of the Month: The team.

American League West:
Texas Rangers (13-12): One of the bigger surprises, not so much because they are doing well, but because they lead their division. The team has continued their trend of hitting, but has sprinkled in some worthwhile pitching. The rotation has been able to keep them in some games, but the bullpen is carrying a 5.01 earned run average. Without a great improvement there, they won’t be able to contend for too long.
Player of the Month: Kevin Mench
Dud of the Month: Francisco Cordero

Oakland Athletics (12-12): The A’s are up to their old tricks of starting off the season poorly. At 12-12, they are right where they were last year heading into May. The strength of the team, starting pitching, has struggled out of the gate as no starter has an earned run average below 4.00. The hitting remains a problem despite the uncharacteristically hot start from third baseman Eric Chavez. We’ve learned in the past not to judge the A’s on April.
Player of the Month: Chavez
Dud of the Month: Huston Street

Los Angeles Angels (12-13): The bulk of the Angels’ struggles center around the team’s .305 on-base percentage. Garret Anderson and Vladimir Guerrero have powered the offense, but the team has a league-worst 47 walks. John Lackey and Kelvim Escobar have led the staff, but now Escobar finds himself in a familiar state… hurt.
Player of the Month: Scot Shields
Dud of the Month: Jeff Weaver

Seattle Mariners (11-15): Four of the five starting pitchers carry earned run averages under 5.00. The only one? Felix Hernandez with a 5.06. He is fifth in the American League in strikeouts, but he hasn’t been able to keep guys off base (1.61 WHIP). Offensively, Adrian Beltre has been a huge disappointment… AGAIN! He does have seven stolen bases, but he’s hitting .189.
Player of the Month: Jarrod Washburn
Dud of the Month: Beltre

National League East:
New York Mets (16-8): Sadly, both Steve Trachsel and Victor Zambrano remain in the rotation ahead of Aaron Heilman. Despite that, the Mets have jumped out to a good start powered by their pitching. Jorge Julio has been brutal out of the pen, too, but picked up nicely by both Duaner Sanchez and Billy Wagner. David Wright is off to a great start at the dish, but has struggled mightily in the field.
Player of the Month: Sanchez
Dud of the Month: Cliff Floyd

Atlanta Braves (10-14): It has only been a month, but the streak is over. This team simply doesn’t have what it takes to grab another NL East crown. They can’t hit and beyond Johns Smoltz and Thomson, they can’t pitch much. On the bright side, Andruw Jones is on pace for another big home run season (48).
Player of the Month: Ryan Langerhans
Dud of the Month: Jeff Francoeur

Philadelphia Phillies (10-14): Another underachieving start for the Phillies sunk by an abysmal rotation outside of Brett Myers. The middle of their lineup has been excellent, but they’ve struggled to string any wins together. Another down month could seriously hamper their chances of contending with the Mets.
Player of the Month: Pat Burrell
Dud of the Month: Ryan Madson

Washington Nationals (8-17): With a 1-7 home record, it’s no wonder the Nats have struggled so much during the season’s first month. Nick Johnson is getting on almost 50% of the time (.455) and newcomer Alfonso Soriano has been excellent, but several others in the lineup have scuffled while the pitching staff has been inconsistent. Now, ace John Patterson is on the disabled list leaving Tony Armas as the most reliable arm. Given his injury woes, that doesn’t bode well.
Player of the Month: Johnson
Dud of the Month: Jose Guillen

Florida Marlins (6-16): This young team is playing exactly to expectations… poorly. With a team salary of about $18 dollars, any win is gravy for this team. The offense sports just five regulars, one of whom is hitting .192 (Mike Jacobs), but the pitching has been solid (team ERA of 4.39). This is still a team that is destined to lose over 100 games.
Player of the Month: Hanley Ramirez
Dud of the Month: Jacobs

National League Central:

Cincinnati Reds (17-8): Landing Bronson Arroyo for Wily Mo Pena has been quite fruitful for the Reds to this point. Arroyo has been excellent leading a pitching staff not expected to do much coming into the season. Brandon Claussen and Eric Milton have continued to pitch poorly, but Arroyo has paired with Aaron Harang for a worthwhile 1-2 punch. The offense remains potent and Edwin Encarnacion and Brandon Phillips have made fans forget that Ken Griffey Jr. is once again back on the disabled list.
Player of the Month: Arroyo
Dud of the Month: Javier Valentin

St. Louis Cardinals (17-8): Everyone knows how amazing Albert Pujols’ April was, but the team as a whole certainly hasn’t hit like they are known to. Two regular hitters have posted OPS under .580 (Encarnacion and Molina). Scott Rolen has missed time and Jim Edmonds has had his problems at the plate with 24 strikeouts. Questions from the staff circle around Jason Isringhausen (and his 6.00 earned run average) rather than Sidney Ponson, surprisingly enough. Chris Carpenter is putting together another Cy Young season thus far.
Player of the Month: Pujols
Dud of the Month: Molina

Houston Astros (16-8): Granted the team has been a beneficiary of a light schedule; any headway the team can make as they await a Roger Clemens decision is great, especially considering their start from last year. Four starters have kept earned run averages below 3.00 including Taylor Buchholz’s 2.05. The offense has been able to pick up Preston Wilson and account for his 26 strikeouts with stepping up their performances.
Player of the Month: Lance Berkman, Buchholz
Dud of the Month: Andy Pettitte

Chicago Cubs (13-10): Everything the Cubs have done, good or bad, is overshadowed by the devastating loss of Derrek Lee. He joins Mark Prior and Kerry Wood on the disabled list. With him out, Juan Pierre and Aramis Ramirez need to step up immediately before the Central division laps the Cubs. Greg Maddux is doing his part to keep the team in contention in the interim.
Player of the Month: Maddux
Dud of the Month: Ramirez

Milwaukee Brewers (14-11): Everyone’s favorite as surprise team of the season, the Brewers have been solid, if unspectacular. Prince Fielder has arrived and Carlos Lee has really put it all together as the two drive that lineup. The rotation, outside of Chris Capuano, has been sporadic to downright bad (Doug Davis). Derrick Turnbow has come out and shown that last year was no fluke.
Player of the Month: Turnbow
Dud of the Month: Davis

Pittsburgh Pirates (7-19): Despite how bright the future looks with youngsters Zach Duke, Paul Maholm, and Ian Snell, when they are all experiencing growing pains in the same lineup, it’s going to lead to bad things. Mix in the gas can commonly referred to as Oliver Perez and you have a 7-19 record. The silver lining for the team is that three offensive players have OPS above .930.
Player of the Month: Craig Wilson
Dud of the World: Perez

National League West:
Colorado Rockies (15-10): I’m not going to rain on the Rockies’ parade and suggest that the only reason they are atop the West is because it is baseball’s worst division. Instead, I’ll point out that they have achieved this honor after one month despite missing nine games from Todd Helton with a stomach virus and that the offense has a higher road OPS to date with .929. A 3.15 bullpen earned run average has also contributed to their fast start.
Player of the Month: Brad Hawpe
Dud of the Month: Danny Ardoin

San Francisco Giants (13-11): Jason Schmidt seems to have lost it in terms of his control and overall effectiveness. Noah Lowry went out on the disabled list two innings into his first start of the season. That leaves Jamey Wright as the anchor at the moment making their position in the division tenuous at best. Moises Alou and Omar Vizquel still showing more than adequate signs of life.
Player of the Month: Alou
Dud of the Month: Pedro Feliz

Arizona Diamondbacks (12-13): The D’Backs are scoring more than they are allowing and Brandon Webb has been fantastic as the ace, but half of the pitching staff is toting an earned run average over 5.00. The offense has mixed and matched several players as they continue to look for the winning combination.
Player of the Month: Webb
Dud of the Month: Orlando Hudson

Los Angeles Dodgers (12-13): Of the six regular hitters, two have OPS totals above .697. That won’t win you too many ballgames even with a team earned run average of 3.81. Danys Baez has been great replacing Eric Gagne, his Sunday performance in San Diego notwithstanding. Rafael Furcal and Jeff Kent can’t stay this bad, meaning the Dodgers should improve and could find themselves in the driver’s seat a month from now.
Player of the Month: Brad Penny
Dud of the Month: Furcal and Kent

San Diego Padres (9-15): If only Jake Peavy was pitching as well as Woody Williams and Chris Young, the Padres might have a few more wins. Instead Peavy has scuffled until finally getting on track against San Francisco last night. The offense is putrid, to say the least. No regular player has an average of .271 or OPS above .776. It is impossible for words to describe just how awful that is for a team.
Player of the Month: Trevor Hoffman
Dud of the Month: the entire lineup

Thursday: 04.27.2006

Rumors, News, & Notes…

  • It looks like Tony Clark has said he'd waive his no-trade clause in a move out of Arizona, with the Chicago Cubs being mentioned as a destination. He isn't complaining or demanding a trade, but rather saying that if moving him out of the Arizona will help the team, then so be it.
  • The Florida Marlins apparently offered Dontrelle Willis to the New York Mets for David Wright. Of course they did, because that would be an excellent deal for them. I like Willis just fine, but he's not worth Wright, not by a long shot.
  • Offseason acquisition Juan Cruz will replace Russ Ortiz in the Arizona Diamondbacks' rotation, a move that is looooong overdue.
  • Though rumors have leaked that the group headed by Ted Lerner has been selected as the next owners of the Washington Nationals, the office of Bob DuPuy has quashed the idea saying a winner will be picked by mid-June.
  • After seeing the video, it is hard to suggest anything but a long suspension for Tampa Bay Devil Rays' prospect Delmon Young. The rest of the season would be sufficient.
  • Akinori Otsuka will take over as the Texas Rangers closer in place of Francisco Cordero starting this weekend. Cordero has blown five straight saves and carries and 11.70 ERA in 10 innings.
  • Richie Sexson cites the bevy of top-flight pitchers the Seattle Mariners have faced that has led to their early season struggles. I especially like when he refer to Justin Verlander as "Detroit's guy that throws 100."
  • After already losing Derrek Lee to a broken wrist, the Chicago Cubs held their collective breath after a finger injury to catcher Michael Barrett. The sigh of relief came at the news that the finger is sprained and not broken.
  • Cincinnati Reds reliever Ryan Wagner was shocked when he didn't make the club coming out of spring, but he feels he is making strides towards coming back whether the numbers show it or not.
  • In the Most Accurate Description category, San Diego Padres manager Bruce Bochy wins for labelling his team as "awful". They didn't look good backing into a NL West title last year and they look even worse occupying the basement thus far in 2006.